The Courage to Ask: Feedback as a Leadership Practice

Insights Blog | 3 min read | July 9, 2026

- By Lisa Kinney, Nexstar Network Leadership & Culture Coach

There are two versions of you as a leader: the one you intend to be, and the one your team actually experiences. The gap between intention and impact is where leadership effectiveness is either built or, unfortunately, lost.

Most leaders care deeply about how they show up. They want to be strong communicators, effective at building strategy, and focused on developing their people. Still, there’s often a difference between how you intend to lead and the reality. The only way to understand that disconnect is through honest feedback from those around you.

The higher up you are, the less honest feedback you receive. Rarely will someone walk up and tell you that your communication style is creating confusion, that recognition is lacking, or that the way a conflict was handled left people feeling demoralized. Instead, they’ll say everything’s fine while feeling frustrated, or they’ll talk about their concerns with everyone but you. People in your company have opinions about how you show up, but they hesitate to share for fear of your response or the impact it may have on their career. It takes real courage to tell a leader their behavior is having a negative impact on the team or the business.

That means it’s up to you to invite feedback and show that it’s safe to give. Feedback focuses on clarity and the opportunity to improve, rather than criticism or tearing someone down.

The Value of Feedback

There’s a common belief that asking for feedback signals weakness or uncertainty. It actually signals the opposite. It takes confidence to say, “I want to know how I can lead this team better.” When a leader asks, “What could I be doing better?” it shows awareness that blind spots exist and that growth is ongoing. It also shows that others’ perspectives matter. Asking for feedback helps build trust and reinforces a culture where feedback is expected and valued.

Another reason to ask for feedback is retention. Finding great employees is challenging, and losing them can be costly. Creating an environment where people want to stay requires intentional effort, and leadership plays a central role. One of the top reasons people leave a job is their relationship with their manager. Developing yourself, along with your leadership team, becomes essential when retention is a priority. High performers, especially, have strong expectations of themselves and those leading them. Showing the humility to ask for feedback, along with the discipline to act on it, sends a powerful message.

The Next Step: 360 Assessments

Once the importance of feedback is clear, the next step is understanding how to gather it. A structured approach, such as a leadership 360 assessment, can be especially valuable. A 360 assessment gathers input from people who experience your leadership from different perspectives. It allows direct reports, peers, and your manager to provide anonymous feedback, which often leads to more candid input. Over time, patterns begin to emerge, blind spots become more visible, and the full impact of your leadership becomes clearer.

After feedback is collected, the real work begins. Following up with a clear development plan focused on the areas identified during the process is essential. A thoughtful plan increases the likelihood of follow-through and supports meaningful improvement in leadership capability.

Asking for feedback can feel uncomfortable, and that’s exactly why most leaders avoid it. Feedback acts as a mirror — one that leaders need but don’t always choose to look into. Growth, however, isn’t driven by comfort. It comes from facing what isn’t yet known and being willing to hear the truth.

So ask. Ask your team. Ask your peers. Ask the people who experience your leadership every day. Because if you’re not actively seeking the truth about how you lead, you’re leading on assumption, not reality. And that’s a risk no leader can afford to take. Have the courage to be one of the few leaders brave enough to ask for the feedback.


If you’re a Nexstar member and could benefit from a leadership 360 assessment, contact Lisa Kinney, Leadership and Culture Coach.

Members may also consider attending our Leadership & Culture Workshop, August 11-13, 2026, hosted by our welcoming members at Miller’s Services in Gloucester, VA. Click here for details and to RSVP!

And if you’re exploring ways to strengthen your leadership team, Nexstar offers coaching, training, peer connection, and proven frameworks designed specifically for independent home services contractors. Whether you’re ready for a deeper conversation or just beginning to evaluate what’s next, we’d welcome the opportunity to learn more about your goals and share how we support leaders like you.

Contact


Related Posts